Cacti of Ontario's Journal

Hollingshead, D. S., 2024
Curator, Research Coordinator
Ottawa Cacti and Succulent Sanctuary

Enhancing Opuntia (Cactaceae) Species Identification Through Dynamic Monitoring Platforms And Herbarium Specimens

Introduction:
Opuntia, a genus within the Cactaceae family, comprises a diverse group of species with unique morphological characteristics. Identifying Opuntia species in situ can be challenging due to their variability. To address this issue, utilizing dynamic monitoring platforms like iNaturalist in conjunction with herbarium specimens can significantly enhance the accuracy and efficiency of Opuntia species identification.

Importance of Dynamic Monitoring Platforms:
iNaturalist serves as an essential tool for biodiversity monitoring and citizen science. This platform functions as a crowd-sourced database where individuals can contribute observations of various species, including Opuntia cacti, fostering a collaborative approach to data collection and species identification. The core function of iNaturalist lies in its utilization of artificial intelligence for image recognition and a community of experts for data verification, enabling users to accurately document and classify biodiversity. The significance of iNaturalist extends to its role in generating real-time data on species distributions, phenological patterns, and responses to environmental changes, thereby enriching scientific research and conservation efforts. By engaging a global community of naturalists, researchers, and enthusiasts, iNaturalist promotes public participation in scientific endeavors, enhances environmental awareness, and facilitates the monitoring and preservation of biodiversity on a large scale. This platform stands as a powerful tool for citizen science, uniting people worldwide in the shared goal of understanding and safeguarding biodiversity.

Dynamic monitoring platforms such as iNaturalist provide a valuable tool for documenting observations of Opuntia species in situ. By crowdsourcing observations from a global community of citizen scientists and experts, iNaturalist offers real-time data that can aid in the identification of Opuntia species based on location, phenology, and ecological associations. This platform not only facilitates rapid species identification but also contributes to the ongoing monitoring and conservation efforts of Opuntia populations worldwide.

Tracking disjunct occurrences and potential range expansions of Opuntia species is crucial for understanding their ecological dynamics and responses to environmental changes. Dynamic monitoring platforms enable researchers to detect and document these occurrences in real-time, providing valuable insights into species' movements and adaptations. By comparing current observations with historically preserved herbarium specimens, scientists can identify shifts in species distributions, assess the impact of climate change, and predict potential range expansions. This integrated approach not only enhances our understanding of Opuntia species' resilience but also informs conservation strategies to protect these unique cacti in the face of evolving environmental conditions.

Collaboration with Herbarium Specimens:
Incorporating herbarium specimens into the identification process adds a historical and comparative dimension to Opuntia species recognition. Herbarium collections house a wealth of preserved specimens with detailed morphological characteristics, allowing for direct comparisons with in situ observations. By combining data from dynamic monitoring platforms like iNaturalist with information from preserved herbarium specimens, researchers can create comprehensive species profiles, refine taxonomic classifications, and contribute to the broader understanding of Opuntia diversity and distribution.

Conclusion:
The integration of dynamic monitoring platforms like iNaturalist with herbarium specimens offers a powerful approach to identifying Opuntia species in situ. This collaborative method not only enhances species identification accuracy but also promotes data sharing, community engagement, and conservation efforts. By leveraging the strengths of both live observations and historical collections, researchers can advance our knowledge of Opuntia diversity and ecology, ultimately contributing to the preservation of these iconic cactus species.

Argus, G.W., C.J. Keddy, K.M. Pryor and D.J. White. (1982-1987). Atlas of the Rare Vascular Plants of Ontario, G.W. Argus & D.J. White (eds.). National Museum of Natural Sciences, Botany Division, Ottawa, Ont.

Beschel, R.E. (1967). The cactus at Kaladar. Blue Bill (Quarterly Bulletin of the Kingston Field Naturalists) 14(2): 11-12.

Benson, L. (1982). The Cacti of the United States and Canada. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA, 1044 pp.

Britton, N. L., and Rose J. N. (1920). The Cactaceae. Vol 1. Carnegie Institute of Washington, Washington, DC., 236 pp.

Burgess, T.J.W. (1882). Notes From Canada. Botanical Gazette Vol. 7, Issue 8/9, pages 95-96.

Burgess, T.J.W. (1888-1889). The Lake Erie shore as a botanizing ground. Journal and Proceedings of the Hamilton Association 5: 41-59.

Consaul, L., S. Darbyshire, and A. Dugal. (1998). The status of the fragile prickly pear cactus (Opuntia fragilis) in Nepean, Ontario. Trail and Landscape 32: 175-181

Cota-Sánchez, J. H. (2002). Taxonomy, distribution, rarity status and uses of Canadian cacti. Haseltonia 9: 17-25.

Drezner, T. D. (2017). North and South: Morphological Variability in the Endangered Opuntia cespitosa in Canada and Variation with Environmental Conditions. Castanea, 82(1), 8–23. http://www.jstor.org/stable/26353871

Drezner, T. D. (2017). Shade, reproductive effort and growth of the endangered native cactus, Opuntia humifusa RAF. In Point Pelee National Park, Canada. The Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society 144(2), 179-190.

Drezner, T. D. (2019). Vegetation associations of the endangered Opuntia cespitosa (Prickly Pear, Cactaceae) and microsite variation in Point Pelee National Park, Ontario, Canada. Physical Geography. 42. 1-17.

Frego, K.A., and R.J. Staniforth. (1986). The Brittle Prickly-pear Cactus, Opuntia fragilis, in the boreal forest of southern Manitoba. Canadian Field-Naturalist 100(2): 229-236.

Frego, K.A., and R.J. Staniforth. (2000). Ecological History and Population Dynamics of a Disjunct Population of Brittle Prickly-pear Cactus, Opuntia fragilis (Cactaceae), in eastern Ontario. Canadian Field-Naturalist 114(1): 98-105.

Gorelick, R. (2015). Northern Range Limit of Opuntia fragilis and the Cactaceae is 56°N, Not 58°N. Madroño 62(2), 115-123, https://doi.org/10.3120/0024-9637-62.2.115

Hancock, K., S. Darbyshire, and R. Huntley. (2005). Canada's Kaladar cactus. British Cactus and Succulent Journal 23(2): 50-55.

Hyunh, M. (2023). Tracking the Dispersal of the Endangered Eastern Prickly Pear Cactus (Opuntia cespitosa) by Animal Vectors in Canada. Masters Thesis, York University, Toronto, ON, 119 pp.

Macoun, John, 1831-1920. (1922). Autobiography of John Macoun, M.A. : Canadian explorer and naturalist, assistant director and naturalist to the Geological Survey of Canada, 1831-1920. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.14288/1.0343216

Macoun, J. (1883). Catalogue of Canadian Plants, Part I, Polypetalae. Dawson Brothers, Montreal. 192 pp.

Macoun, J. (1886). Catalogue of Canadian Plants, Part III, Apetalae. Dawson Brothers, Montreal. 395-623 pp.

Majure, L.C. and E. Ribbens. (2012). Chromosome Counts of Opuntia (Cactaceae), Prickly Pear Cacti, in The Midwestern United States and Environmental Factors Restricting the Distribution of Opuntia Fragilis. Haseltonia 2012(17), 58-65.

Majure, L.C., W.S. Judd, P.S. Soltis, and D.E. Soltis. (2017). Taxonomic revision of the Opuntia humifusa complex (Opuntieae: Cactaceae) of the eastern United States. Phytotaxa 290 (1): 001-065.

Moss, E. H. (1959). Flora of Alberta. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, ON, 546 pp.

Mottiar, Y., P. Chafe, and E. Ribbens. (2015). Imperfect Flowers of Opuntia fragilis in Kaladar, Ontario, Haseltonia 20: 22-25.

Oldham, M. & Brinker, S. (2009). Rare Vascular Plants of Ontario, Fourth Edition. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.19537.84324.

Ontario Bureau of Mines (1896). Fifth Report of the Ontario Bureau of Mines; Ontario Bureau of Mines,
Annual Report, 1895, v.5, 51p.

Parfitt, B. D. (1991). Biosystematics of the Opuntia polyacantha complex (Cactaceae) of western North America. Ph.D. Dissertation. Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, 115 pp.

Parks Canada Agency. (2023). Report on the Progress of Recovery Strategy Implementation for the Eastern Prickly Pear Cactus (Opuntia humifusa) in Canada (2018 – 2022). Species at Risk Act Recovery Strategy Report Series. Parks Canada Agency, Ottawa. 9 pp.

Reznicek, A. A. (1982). The cactus in southwestern Ontario. Ont. Field. Biol. 36: 35-38

Reznicek, A. & Catling, P. (1989). Flora of Long Point, Regional Municipality of Haldimand-Norfolk, Ontario. 28. 99-175.

Ribbens, E. (2008). Opuntia fragilis: taxonomy, distribution, and ecology. Haseltonia 14: 94-110.

Staniforth, J., Cody, W.J., and Frego, K.A. (2002). Bill Dore's notes on the Kaladar cactus (Opuntia fragilis). Canadian Field-Naturalist 116(4): 547-550.

Torrey, J., Bigelow, J. M., & Engelmann, G. (1857). Report on the botany of the expedition /by Professor John Torrey. [s.n.],. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.41563

Consaul, L., S. Darbyshire, and A. Dugal. 1998. The status of the fragile prickly pear cactus (Opuntia fragilis) in Nepean, Ontario. Trail and Landscape 32: 175-181

v.32:no.4 (1998)
Pages 175-181

https://archive.org/details/traillandscape32ottac/page/156/mode/1up

The Importance of Studying Disjunct, Northeastern Opuntia (Cactaceae) Distributions and Populations:

1. Biodiversity conservation: Opuntia species are an integral part of the ecosystem and contribute to the overall biodiversity of an area. Understanding their distributions and populations helps in assessing their conservation status and implementing appropriate measures for their protection.
2. Habitat assessment: Studying the presence or absence of Opuntia species in different habitats provides insights into their habitat requirements and preferences. This information can be used to identify suitable habitats for restoration efforts or to monitor changes in the landscape that could impact their populations.
3. Range expansion and contraction: Disjunct distributions of Opuntia species might indicate historical range expansions or contractions due to various factors such as climate change, land use practices, or natural events. By studying these distributions, researchers can gain a better understanding of the species ecological history and its response to environmental changes.
4. Evolutionary patterns: The study of disjunct Opuntia populations can shed light on evolutionary processes such as speciation, genetic differentiation, and adaptation. By examining the genetic diversity and relationships among populations, researchers can explore the mechanisms driving their divergence and potentially uncover new insights into evolution and adaptation.
5. Plant-insect interactions: Opuntia species often have specific interactions with certain insect species, such as their pollinators or herbivores. Studying their distributions and populations can help understand the mutual dependencies and coevolutionary dynamics between Opuntia cacti and associated insects, providing valuable insights into the functioning of ecosystems.
6. Conservation management: Knowledge of the distributions and population dynamics of Opuntia species is crucial for effective conservation planning and management strategies. It helps identify areas of high conservation value, prioritize conservation efforts, and implement measures to mitigate threats like habitat loss, invasive species, or overexploitation.

Overall, studying disjunct, northeastern Opuntia distributions and populations allows for a better understanding of their ecological roles, evolutionary history, and conservation needs. This knowledge is essential for developing informed conservation strategies, promoting sustainable land management practices, and maintaining the long-term viability of these important cactus species.

The rediscovery of a reproductive population of O. polyacantha Haw. in Ontario, Canada is highly significant for several reasons. Firstly, it confirms the continued existence of this species in the region, which was previously delisted. This discovery provides valuable evidence and support for the conservation of O. polyacantha Haw.

Additionally, the rediscovery highlights the importance of thorough and accurate documentation of species. It emphasizes the need for ongoing research and monitoring efforts to ensure the preservation of biodiversity. This finding contributes to our understanding of the distribution, habitat requirements, population dynamics, and conservation status of native Opuntia cacti in Ontario.

Furthermore, the rediscovery of a reproductive population opens up possibilities for studying the genetic diversity and evolutionary history of these cacti. It allows researchers, who have otherwise dedicated their efforts to the preservation and study of cacti, to further investigate and contribute to our knowledge of these fascinating plants.

Overall, the rediscovery of a reproductive population of O. polyacantha Haw. in Ontario, Canada represents a significant milestone in our understanding and conservation of these cacti species.

"Notes from Canada"

T J W Burgess
Published in Botanical Gazette, in 1882, in volume 7, issue 8/9, pages 95-96

https://biostor.org/reference/209928

" Notes from Canada. —

Having in the latter part of June,
made a collecting tour with my friends. Professor Macoun, Dominion Naturalist; Mr. Wm. Saunders, Editor of the Canadian Entomologist; and Mr. James Macoun, to Point Pelee, Essex Co., Ontario, the most southern point on the mainland in Canada, a list of the rarer plants found there might not be void of interest to some of the readers of the Gazette. The list is chiefly remarkable for the southern nature of most of the species enumerated, some of
them so much so, that I had not dreamed of finding them within our
boreal confines. To this locality never before having been thoroughly explored, may be attributed the seemingly extraordinary fact, that
or the plants mentioned, the first eleven have not, I believe, been
heretofore recorded as found in Canada, while the remaining ten
have but very rarely been noted.

Opuntia Rafinesquii, Eng."

Opuntia polyacantha Haw. (Cactaceae) was previously excluded from the "Atlas of the Rare Vascular Plants of Ontario" as an unconfirmed species.

Argus, G.W., C.J. Keddy, K.M. Pryor and D.J. White. 1982-1987. Atlas of the Rare Vascular Plants of Ontario, G.W. Argus & D.J. White (eds.). National Museum of
Natural Sciences, Botany Division, Ottawa, Ont.

"Excluded species of Cactaceae / Espèces de Cactaceae exclues

J/SI - unconfirmed/situation incertaine

USI Opuntia polyacantha Haw."

https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/109262#page/224/mode/1up